How Iteration-itis Kills Good Ideas

How Iteration-itis Kills Good Ideas – Scott Anthony @ Harvard Business Review via .

“We never see any good ideas,” lamented a senior executive. “People bring us ideas. But they just don’t have any . . . magic.”

At first, I found the comment surprising. I had just begun to get to know the company, and it seemed to me to be brimming with innovation energy, particularly among young employees who would regularly throw out creative “What if’s” during casual conversations.

A month later, it was clear that the problem — as is almost always the case — wasn’t a lack of raw ideas. Instead, there was a problem with the process that an idea generator had to go through before they stood in front of senior leadership. The company, it turned out, had a deep case of iteration-itis.

You see, before anything made it onto the agenda of the top management’s biweekly meeting, it was vetted. And screened. And debated. And re-jiggered. The idea generator had to show the idea to their line manager. To key functional representatives. To key staff members of senior leaders. Maybe even to one or two members of leadership. Every person who saw the idea would express a clear point of view, and the poor idea generator had to figure out how to integrate seemingly contradictory feedback.

Read more… There are some parallels with designing products too 🙂

Make a robot friend with Adafruit’s CRICKIT – A Creative Robotics & Interactive Construction Kit. It’s an add-on to our popular Circuit Playground Express, FEATHER and other platforms to make and program robots with CircuitPython, MakeCode, and Arduino. Start controlling motors, servos, solenoids. You also get signal pins, capacitive touch sensors, a NeoPixel driver and amplified speaker output. It complements & extends your boards so you can still use all the goodies on the microcontroller, now you have a robotics playground as well.

Join 7,500+ makers on Adafruit’s Discord channels and be part of the community! http://adafru.it/discord

CircuitPython in 2018 – Python on Microcontrollers is here!

Have an amazing project to share? Join the SHOW-AND-TELL every Wednesday night at 7:30pm ET on Google+ Hangouts.

Join us every Wednesday night at 8pm ET for Ask an Engineer!

Follow Adafruit on Instagram for top secret new products, behinds the scenes and more https://www.instagram.com/adafruit/

Maker Business — Rethink Robotics closes shop. Long live collaborative robots #makerbusiness

Wearables — Zip it up

Electronics — Serial overkill

Biohacking — Biohacking Resources – Books, Talks and Podcasts

Python for Microcontrollers — CircuitPython @ Hackaday SuperCon #ICYMI @circuitpython @micropython @ThePSF #Python

Get the only spam-free daily newsletter about wearables, running a "maker business", electronic tips and more! Subscribe at AdafruitDaily.com !


  1. This is a fundamental point, not just in engineering, but in business as a whole. Whether you are pitching an idea for a new product, or going for a job interview, of all the people you meet along the way, there is only ONE person whose job it is to say yes. Everyone else is there to say no. The chances are that at least one of those people will not understand what you are saying, or will have a personal reason not to go ahead with it.

    This is why it is important in every business (but particularly large ones) that the people at the top make time to talk to the people who actually do things in the business, rather than the layers of administrators.

  2. Heh, you’re so worn out by the time you get any action on it that you start to figure “what’s the use” and don’t bother telling anyone about that new spark of ingenuity that could blow the doors off the world.

    Consensus building and committee rule kill off just about any business that depends on innovation. Ideas tend to be free flowing and shoot off in odd directions that are totally anathema to leadership as they want rigid planning and control over a process that works best when allowed freedom.

    Unfortunately, Dilbert is not fiction, but a full and continuous documentary on businesses that work this way.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.