“The scientific spirit has cast out the demons, and presented us with nature clothed in her right mind and living under the reign of law. It has given us, for the sorceries of the alchemist, the beautiful laws of chemistry; for the dreams of the astrologer, the sublime truths of astronomy; for the wild visions of cosmogony, the monumental records of geology; for the anarchy of diabolism, the laws of God.” – James A. Garfield, 1867
For the second installment of Political Science, we take a look at the complicated scientific legacy of James Garfield. Nominated at the raucous 1880 Republican National Convention against his own protests, Garfield defeated Democrat Winfield Scott Hancock by the narrowest popular vote margin in US presidential election history to become the twentieth president of the United States. Inaugurated on March 4, 1981, Garfield was shot by Charles J. Guiteau, unstable office-seeker turned assassin, on July 2 of the same year. The president died on September 19 after two months of agony. The only president to serve a shorter term than Garfield is William Henry Harrison.
Though a largely forgotten president best remembered for his tragic assassination, Garfield was a unique man with an interesting story. Raised in abject poverty (“the last of the log cabin presidents”), he was a longtime supporter of civil rights and the youngest major general of the Civil War. He served nine terms in the House and was the Senator-Elect of Ohio at the time of his presidential nomination. The lack of interest today in Garfield’s administration is understandable. Serving as president for such a short period, with much of that time spent on his deathbed, he did little more during his term than select his cabinet and make appointments. However, the life and death of Garfield still made their mark on the sciences, and as a result, the world.
- James Garfield was intensely intelligent and an excellent academic. When he was still a student, he was hired to teach classes of his own on subjects such as literature, ancient languages and mathematics. After graduating with honors from Williams College, Garfield returned to teaching full time, adding geology to his catalog of classes. While serving in Congress, Garfield, the former science teacher, produced an original proof of the Pythagorean theorem, which so impressed the New-England Journal of Education that it stated the Congressman’s work was “something on which the members of both houses can unite without distinction of party.”
- Though unable to do much with his time in office, Garfield’s inaugural address gave some indication of what he hoped to achieve during his tenure. During the speech, Garfield asserted that the federal government should provide support for agricultural research:
“The interests of agriculture deserve more attention from the Government than they have yet received. The farms of the United States afford homes and employment for more than one-half our people, and furnish much the largest part of all our exports. As the Government lights our coasts for the protection of mariners and the benefit of commerce, so it should give to the tillers of the soil the best lights of practical science and experience.”
- Garfield’s shooting led to a number of innovations. While Garfield was being treated for his wounds, the 100° F weather in Washington was adding to the president’s misery. Looking to help any way they could, a group of naval engineers created a primitive air conditioner, which brought the temperature in the president’s room down by about 20°. There wouldn’t be another attempt to artificially cool the White House until the Taft administration.
- Alexander Graham Bell was greatly troubled by the news of president’s suffering and the concerning fact that Garfield’s doctors had not been able to find the bullet lodged in his body. Bell worked frantically to create a working metal detector, which he called an “induction balance,” to find the bullet and save the president. Though effective in tests, Bell was unsuccessful on the two occasions that he was able to use his invention on Garfield. But it is worth noting that the interference of Garfield’s possessive physician, Doctor (his for-real first name!) Willard Bliss, was likely to blame for the latter of these two failures. Though the original purpose of the induction balance could not be achieved, the device would later prove useful in searching for bullets in many other wounded patients and was ultimately the prototype for future metal detectors.
- Perhaps the most significant positive result of Garfield’s suffering was that it likely accelerated the acceptance of antiseptics in America. Though widely used in Europe, American doctors had continued to dismiss germ theory and the idea of infection. As a result, the wounded president was forced to endure many unwashed fingers and unsterilized instruments being plunged into his wounds to search for the elusive bullet. Garfield’s body was riddled with infection and covered with abscesses, but Doctor Willard Bliss did not believe in the antiseptic practises of Joseph Lister and did all he could to shut out other practitioners so none could object to his methods. As with any historical diagnosis, there are some conflicting opinions, but many now argue that the president could have survived the bullet wound had it been left entirely alone and that it was Garfield’s treatment which led to blood poisoning and his death. Even Garfield’s attacker would make the claim that “the doctors killed Garfield, I just shot him.” And while Guiteau was considered so uniquely insane that his brain was dissected for science, a number of medical journals and doctors agreed with him on this point.
It’s impossible to know exactly what kind of president Garfield would have been given more time, but there was incredible promise with an abolitionist, war hero, mathematician, geologist and supporter of agricultural science in the White House. His life and death are too fascinating for his name to rest very comfortably on a list of unremarkable presidents. It’s also hard not to be impressed by the efforts and innovations that were so numerous during the period surrounding his death.
For further reading, the dramatic stories of President James Garfield, Alexander Graham Bell, Charles Guiteau and President Chester A. Arthur are all told in Candice Millard’s book Destiny of the Republic: A Tale of Madness, Medicine and the Murder of a President.
You can also hear an abridged version of Garfield’s life in the Washington Post’s excellent “Presidential” Podcast:
In case you missed the first installment of this series: