Today’s post is about Open Hardware Licenses CC BY-SA, CERN, TAPR… first. What are Open source licenses?
Open source licenses are licenses that comply with the Open Source Definition — they allow software to be freely used, modified, and shared. With code it’s pretty clear what open-source licenses there are to choose from. Usually the developer picks on that is OSI certified from the list, there are few popular ones, and a complete list. The popular ones include:
- Apache License 2.0
- BSD 3-Clause “New” or “Revised” license
- BSD 2-Clause “Simplified” or “FreeBSD” license
- GNU General Public License (GPL)
- GNU Library or “Lesser” General Public License (LGPL)
- MIT license
- Mozilla Public License 2.0
- Common Development and Distribution License
- Eclipse Public License version 2.0
The OSI has a good FAQ here as well.
For hardware, there are a few licenses to choose from. Keep in mind, hardware is a little different than code which relies on copyright for protection and licensing. For hardware you generally only have patents and/or trademarks to lean on for legal protections for the designs, however – there are hardware licenses that specifically show the intent of the designer.
For a great overview of patents, trademarks, and copyright in relation to hardware, OSWHA has a hardware section.
- Copyright law offers protection for “original works of authorship” which are “fixed in a tangible medium.” This means that original and creative elements of your product may be protected by copyright law.
- Trademark law protects “source identifiers”, which may include any brand names, product names, logos, or even the design and packaging of your product (more on this later).
- Patent law protects functional inventions that are “novel” and “nonobvious”, when the inventor applies for protection from the US Patent & Trademark Office.
And more specific to hardware…
- Copyright: While certain hardware elements might be creative, the creativity is often constrained by functionality, which prevents most physical aspects of most hardware from being protected by copyright. For example, the way in which parts of a 3D printer’s extruder work together is governed by functional concerns. That means that it cannot be protected by copyright law.
- Trademark: While trademark law may protect the names, logos, and other elements that signal who the producer of the product is, in most cases trademark law do not protect the physical object itself.
- Patent: The requirement that functional inventions be “novel” and “nonobvious” are high legal bars that few inventions meet. Additionally, patents are very expensive to obtain and the process is quite complicated, usually requiring help from specialized lawyers. You must take affirmative steps to obtain patent protection for your hardware.
At this time (and when I wrote about this in 2012), it appears the majority of shipping Open-source hardware still uses Creative Commons-Share-Alike-Attribution for the hardware, with a MIT license for the software.
So, what are the choices for hardware licenses?
CERN Open Hardware License
The CERN Open Hardware License (OHL or CERN OHL) is a license used in open-source hardware projects. It was created by CERN, which published version 1.0 in March 2011. Version 1.1 was published in July 2011. Version 1.2 was published in September 2013. Version 2.0, which utilizes a simplified language and covers also integrated circuit designs, is currently being drafted.
CERN as in that CERN, The European Organization for Nuclear Research – where the World Wide Web began!
TAPR, The TAPR Open Hardware License
The TAPR Open Hardware License (“OHL”) provides a framework for hardware projects that is similar to the one used for Open Source software. This isn’t as straight-forward as it seems because legal concepts that work well for software (such as copyright and copyleft) don’t neatly fit when dealing with hardware products and the documentation used to create them.
CC BY-SA, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike
Share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format. Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material for any purpose, even commercially. Attribution — You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the licensor endorses you or your use. ShareAlike — If you remix, transform, or build upon the material, you must distribute your contributions under the same license as the original.
Opinion time, CERN is probably the best one, more so with version 2.0. We have a board that was put under CERN, we’ve used CC BY-SA for so long kinda kept going with that. I do not think it matters what hardware license is chosen, besides picking CC BY-SA or CERN at this point to demonstrate your intentions. What tends to happen is a lot of people who like to argue on mailing lists talk about theoretical issues, and edge case licenses while other are shipping hardware.
That said, post up in the comments if you’re publishing open-source software and hardware and use other licenses. There other ones like SolderPad, however, I wanted to post up about these 3 specifically for this article.
Open source hardware month @ Adafruit:
- Open Source Hardware Month at SparkFun – Day 16, 10/16/2016.
- Post not done yet – Day 15, 10/15/2016.
- The RepRap Project Self-Replicating Open-Source 3D Printing – Day 14, 10/13/2019.
- The first 2 orders at Adafruit… now up to 2,161,166 orders – Day 13, 10/13/2019.
- Photos of the first Arduino (2005) – Day 12, 10/12 2019.
- In 2010 there were 13 Open Source Hardware companies that were making $1 million or more… – Day 11, 10/11/2019
- Opening Hardware 2010 at Eyebeam in NYC – Day 10, 10/10/2019.
- The Open Source Gift Guide, the early years – Day 9, 10/9/2019 (posted it on 10/10/2019, whoops)
- Before the iPhone, before the Raspberry Pi, before Amazon Echo Show, there was Chumby – Day 8, 10/8/2019.
- Mitch Altman Open-source hardware pioneer – Day 7, 10/7/2019.
- The Open Source logo(s) – Day 6, 10/6/2019.
- Open Source Hardware events all month long, EVENTS! – Day 5, 10/5/2019.
- Open Source Hardware Certifications and more! – Day 4, 10/4/2019.
- Teuthis Open Source MP3 Player 2001 – Daisy by Raphael Abrams – Day 3, 10/3/2019.
- What is the Open-Source Hardware Definition? – Day 2, 10/2/2019.
- Open hardware summit – Limor “Ladyada” Fried keynote 2010 – Day 1, 10/1/2019.
October is open-source hardware month! Every single day in October we’ll be posting up some open-source stories from the last decade (and more!) about open-source hardware, open-source software, and beyond!
Have an open-source hardware (or software) success story? A person, company, or project to celebrate? An open-source challenge? Post up here in the comments or email firstname.lastname@example.org, we’ll be looking for, and using the tag #OHM2019 online as well! Check out all the events going on here!